Novig Loses New York Preliminary Injunction Over Swaps
A Manhattan federal judge denied Novig a preliminary injunction against New York's gambling laws on November 10, finding at this stage that its sports contracts are not federal "swaps". New York can require Novig to get a state license or stop listing them. Novig appealed to the Second Circuit the same day.
Novig is the operator that retired its Novig Cash sweepstakes model in August and moved players onto a CFTC-designated exchange. This ruling is the answer to the question that move raised: does a federal exchange license let it serve New York, where dual-currency sweepstakes casinos are already banned? For now, the court says no. Novig sued New York after winning its CFTC exchange license, and this is the ruling on its preliminary injunction motion in that case.
What did the judge decide in Novig v. New York?
Judge Colleen McMahon of the Southern District of New York denied the preliminary injunction that Ludlow Exchange, LLC, which does business as Novig, asked for against Attorney General Letitia James and the New York State Gaming Commission. The 35-page opinion holds:
"At this preliminary injunction stage, the Court concludes that Novig's contracts are not 'swaps' within the meaning of the Commodities Exchange Act, so New York can apply its gambling and sports-wagering laws to Novig's activity by requiring it either to obtain a state gambling license or to prohibit the listing and trading of those contracts on Novig's designated contract market."
She ruled on likelihood of success alone and did not reach the other injunction factors. This is the follow-up to her August 11 refusal of Novig's emergency restraining order. The wider preliminary injunction she was asked to decide next has now gone the same way.
Why did the court reject Novig's federal preemption argument?
The opinion turns down every preemption route Novig offered. On the claim that it could not comply with both federal and state law, it does not hedge: "Novig's argument is ridiculous." The court points out that Novig "certainly could" get a New York license, "as it did in Colorado, before it reversed course," and "could implement geofencing so that it serves only customers who are physically in New York." The opinion records that Novig held a Colorado Internet Sports Betting Operator license from 2023 and later handed it back.
The judge was also sharp about the federal regulator. On October 19 the CFTC published two documents in the Federal Register: a proposed rule to define sports event contracts as swaps, and an interim final rule saying casino-style gambling products "are not swaps." The opinion calls them "inherently contradictory and cannot be reconciled," and says the CFTC's change of position "appears calculated to influence the outcome of the ongoing litigation." It goes further on the CFTC's August 11 order telling Kalshi to keep operating its exchange while New York sought to stop it, which we reported at the time. That order, the court wrote, "smacks of a collusive effort between a regulator and regulatee to generate a claim for conflict preemption."
What happens next in Novig's Second Circuit appeal?
Novig's notice of interlocutory appeal (entry 74) went in on November 10, and the docket shows the record went to the Second Circuit on November 12. The ruling does not order Novig to do anything. It refuses to stop New York from acting.
The Second Circuit is not a fresh start for Novig. The opinion records that on November 4 New York told the court a Second Circuit motions panel had already denied an injunction pending appeal in three consolidated cases brought by Kalshi and Coinbase "which raise essentially the same issues as this case," in a non-precedential summary order. A merits panel will take up those appeals, and no argument date has been set. We covered the start of that fight in Kalshi's Connecticut appeal.
Are sports event contracts swaps? Where the courts stand
The federal appeals courts are split, and McMahon has joined the majority. The Third Circuit held in New Jersey's case that sports event contracts can be swaps. The Ninth Circuit, in Kalshi's Nevada appeal on August 28, and the Sixth Circuit, in the Ohio and Tennessee ruling on September 25, held they are not. Kalshi's own Ninth Circuit motion describes the split the same way. McMahon's opinion relies on both the Sixth and Ninth Circuit readings of the "financial, economic, or commercial consequence" test.
| Court | Case | Are sports event contracts swaps? |
|---|---|---|
| Third Circuit | New Jersey's case | Can be |
| Sixth Circuit | Ohio and Tennessee, September 25 | No |
| Ninth Circuit | Nevada, August 28 | No |
| S.D.N.Y. (Judge McMahon) | Novig v. New York, November 10 | No, at the preliminary injunction stage |
What has happened in Kalshi's Nevada case since?
The newer steps in the Nevada case, alongside Novig's:
| Date | Court | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| November 4, 2026 | Ninth Circuit, No. 25-7516 | Panel "unanimously votes to DENY" rehearing; no judge asked for an en banc vote |
| November 9, 2026 | Ninth Circuit | Kalshi moves to stay the mandate while it petitions the Supreme Court; Kalshi says the Nevada officials oppose |
| November 10, 2026 | S.D.N.Y., No. 1:26-cv-06676 | Novig's preliminary injunction denied |
| November 10, 2026 | S.D.N.Y. | Novig appeals to the Second Circuit |
In that motion Kalshi says Nevada "has obtained a state-court injunction barring Kalshi from offering its sports-event contracts in Nevada" and that "Kalshi has complied with that injunction." Nevada is also one of the states where sweepstakes coin play is barred. Our report on Kalshi's Nevada discovery stay covers the Supreme Court petitions in that case.
Does the Novig ruling affect sweepstakes casinos?
Not directly. Novig and Kalshi are federal exchanges, and nothing in this opinion concerns Gold Coins or Sweeps Coins. The same appeals are now holding up sweepstakes litigation, though. On November 12 the judge in the South Carolina loss-recovery suit, whose defendants include four VGW entities (owner of Chumba Casino) and High 5, said she is "considering staying this action" until the Fourth Circuit decides Kalshiex v. Martin and the Supreme Court acts on "a pending cert. petition in a related case, Flaherty v. Kalshiex (25A1465)." The parties must say by November 20 whether they support a stay. Our report on that lawsuit explains who is suing and why no player collects.
The practical point: a federal or offshore license does not settle whether an app is legal where you are. Our state-by-state legality guide covers sweepstakes casinos, and our best sweepstakes casinos list shows which brands still accept players in each state.
Sources & documents
- Ludlow Exchange, LLC v. James, No. 1:26-cv-06676 (S.D.N.Y.), docket, read through its public feed on November 14, 2026, for entries 72 to 74 and the November 12 transmission to the Second Circuit
- Opinion and order denying preliminary injunction, November 10, 2026 (PDF), entry 73, 35 pages
- Novig notice of appeal, November 10, 2026 (PDF), entry 74
- KalshiEX LLC v. Assad, No. 25-7516 (9th Cir.), docket, read November 14, 2026
- Order denying rehearing and rehearing en banc, November 4, 2026 (PDF), entry 231
- Kalshi motion to stay mandate pending certiorari, November 9, 2026 (PDF), entry 232
- Flaherty v. KalshiEX, LLC, No. 26-299 (U.S.), docket, read November 14, 2026, for the October 30 extension to December 7
- South Carolina Gambling Recovery LLC v. Underdog Sports Holdings, Inc., No. 8:26-cv-02182 (D.S.C.), docket, entry 114, November 12, 2026 text order, and entry 103 for the VGW defendants
21+ only. Sweepstakes play is not a way to make money. If gambling stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER or read our responsible gaming resources.
How we rate the brands involved
Sources & documents
- www.courtlistener.com/docket/73720612/ludlow-exchange-llc-v-james/
- storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.669887/gov.uscourts.nysd.669887.73.0.pdf
- storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.669887/gov.uscourts.nysd.669887.74.0.pdf
- www.courtlistener.com/docket/72237443/kalshiex-llc-v-assad/
- storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca9.819aec5f-bc51-465d-8f8d-4b8aeca97255/gov.uscourts.ca9.819aec5f-bc51-465d-8f8d-4b8aeca97255.231.0.pdf
- storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca9.819aec5f-bc51-465d-8f8d-4b8aeca97255/gov.uscourts.ca9.819aec5f-bc51-465d-8f8d-4b8aeca97255.232.0.pdf
- www.supremecourt.gov/rss/cases/JSON/26-299.json
- www.courtlistener.com/docket/73435998/south-carolina-gambling-recovery-llc-v-underdog-sports-holdings-inc/
Every factual claim in this article maps to one of the sources above - that is the publishing bar, not a goal.
FAQ
Does the ruling make Novig illegal in New York?
No court has ordered Novig to stop. The ruling refuses to stop New York from enforcing its laws while the case continues, and Novig has appealed.
Is this the final decision in Novig's case?
No. It is a preliminary-injunction ruling, made "at this preliminary injunction stage." The case itself is still pending in the district court, and the appeal goes to the Second Circuit.
Will the Supreme Court decide this?
Possibly, but not soon. Kalshi has told the Ninth Circuit it will file a petition for certiorari. New Jersey's petition in Flaherty v. KalshiEX, No. 26-299, is still at the briefing stage: on October 30 the Court extended Kalshi's time to respond to December 7, 2026.
Free SC drops, new casinos, and law changes - for your state.
One email a week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime. If your state bans sweeps, you get law updates instead of offers - that's the point.