Kalshi Preemption: New Jersey Petitions the Supreme Court
- SEP 24, 2026 - The extension Kalshi asked for has been granted, so the October 8 date this article was built around is gone. On September 22, 2026 the docket recorded: "Motion to extend the time to file a response is granted and the time is extended to and including November 9, 2026." Kalshi's brief in opposition is now due November 9, 2026, not October 8, and every sentence putting the deadline at October 8 or describing the request as undecided has been corrected, including the headline deadline in the meta description, the standfirst, the timetable and two FAQ answers. One further entry went on the same day and we have added it to the timetable: an amicus brief by the National Council of Legislators from Gaming States, submitted September 22, 2026. Nothing else moved on a September 24 re-read of the Court's docket file: the Court has not granted review, no conference is scheduled, and the question presented is as filed.
- SEP 21, 2026 - Kalshi has asked to move the October 8 deadline this article is built around. On September 18, 2026 its counsel of record, Neal Kumar Katyal of Milbank, filed a one-page letter requesting a 30-day extension under Rule 30.4, up to and including November 9, 2026, for the brief in opposition. We downloaded the letter and re-read the docket file on September 21: the entry reads "Motion of KalshiEX, LLC for an extension of time submitted" and no order follows it, so October 8 remains the operative date and nothing in this piece was wrong. The standfirst, the timetable and two FAQ answers now carry the pending request so a reader planning around October 8 knows it may move. Every other fact was re-checked against the same docket file today and none of them moved.
New Jersey has asked the Supreme Court to decide whether the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act took away the states' power to police sports bets sold on federally registered markets like Kalshi's. The petition was filed on September 2, 2026, docketed as No. 26-299 on September 8. Kalshi's response was due October 8; the Court granted it a 30-day extension on September 22 and the response is now due November 9, 2026.
The filing is two weeks old and we are late to it; what makes it worth reading today is that the response clock is now the next thing on the docket, and litigants have started citing the petition to put other cases on hold. We pulled the docket file, dated September 15, and the 332-page petition off supremecourt.gov this morning and read them, which is how we check everything we publish.
Nothing about this changes what a sweepstakes player can do today. No sweepstakes brand is a party, no coin balance is affected, and the petition is at the earliest stage a Supreme Court case has. It matters here for one reason: the authority New Jersey is defending is the same authority that eleven states have used to switch sweepstakes casinos off inside their borders. If that authority loses, the reasoning travels.
What question is New Jersey asking the Supreme Court?
One sentence, printed on page (i) of the petition:
Whether the 2010 Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act preempted States from regulating sports bets that occur within their jurisdictions if those bets are offered on markets registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
The case file, as the docket records it:
- Case: Flaherty v. KalshiEX, LLC, No. 26-299
- Petitioners: Mary Jo Flaherty, interim director of the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement, and state Attorney General Jennifer Davenport
- Respondent: KalshiEX, LLC
- Counsel of record: Solicitor General Jeremy M. Feigenbaum
- Decision below: KalshiEX, LLC v. Flaherty, Third Circuit, April 6, 2026
- Filing deadline: pushed from July 5 to September 3 by two extensions granted by Justice Alito
Why do federal appeals courts disagree on Kalshi preemption?
Because they read the word "swap" differently, and both said so about the other.
| Court | Date | Holding on state gambling law |
|---|---|---|
| Third Circuit, KalshiEX v. Flaherty | April 6, 2026 | Kalshi's sports event contracts are likely swaps; the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state sports-gambling law |
| Sixth Circuit, Kalshi v. Schuler | April 24, 2026 | Stay pending appeal denied; "unconvinced" on the preliminary briefing that preemption applies |
| Ninth Circuit, Kalshi v. Assad | August 28, 2026 | Likely not swaps; Dodd-Frank does not preempt state gaming regulation |
Read the word "likely" in that table literally. All three rulings are preliminary-injunction decisions about who is likely to win, not final judgments, and the Third Circuit panel said so of its own. Nor is the Ninth Circuit's the last word in its own court yet: Kalshi petitioned for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc on September 9, so the mandate has not issued.
The Ninth Circuit decision came out of Nevada, and we covered it when the panel upheld the dissolution of Kalshi's injunction three weeks ago. The petition says that opinion "mentioned the Third Circuit's opinion over 20 times while disputing its conclusion, interpretation, and methodology", and quotes the line that does the work: "The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform Act cannot be read as a direct (or indirect) regulation of sports gambling."
New Jersey's own count of the wider fight, in a footnote that lists each case by number: "at least 39 lawsuits across 20 States". Below the circuit level it puts the score at "over 20 decisions", divided "by an 18-4 ratio", with the majority rejecting the Third Circuit's approach. Those are the petitioner's figures, not ours, and a respondent's brief may dispute them.
Those rulings are not abstract to us; we have read them as they came out. The Tenth Circuit left Utah's ban in place on September 8, a Washington judge rejected the same preemption argument and ordered Kalshi to geofence the state in August, and the Second Circuit let Connecticut keep enforcing its gambling laws while Kalshi's appeal runs.
Does this Supreme Court case affect sweepstakes casinos?
Not directly, and the petition never uses the word sweepstakes. The connection is the principle underneath.
New Jersey's argument for why the case matters rests on states' police power over gambling, citing a 1905 Supreme Court case for the proposition that gaming regulation lies "within the police powers of a state" and Murphy for the point that states are "free to act" on sports gambling. That is the same power behind every sweepstakes ban on our map, from Connecticut to Montana. A ruling that a federal financial statute quietly overrode it would be read closely by every operator arguing that its product is not gambling either.
The petition also spells out a consequence for conventional casinos that is easy to miss. If sports bets are swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, then the statute's rule that swaps must be entered into on a designated contract market would mean, in the Ninth Circuit's words quoted at page 18, that "every person placing a sports bet at Caesar's Sportsbook (or anywhere else for that matter) is violating the" Act. The petition makes the same point again at page 22, and spells out the consequence it wants the Court to notice: that federal courts would be "render[ing] all classic sportsbooks unlawful".
What happens next in Kalshi's Supreme Court case?
| Date | Step |
|---|---|
| September 2, 2026 | Petition for certiorari filed |
| September 8, 2026 | Docketed as No. 26-299 |
| September 18, 2026 | Kalshi asks to move the response date to November 9 |
| September 22, 2026 | The motion is granted; the response date moves to November 9. The National Council of Legislators from Gaming States files an amicus brief the same day |
| November 9, 2026 | Kalshi's response due, as the docket now stands |
| Not yet set | Conference, then a grant or denial |
The response date is the one thing on this docket that has already been asked to move. Kalshi's counsel of record, Neal Kumar Katyal, wrote to the Clerk on September 18 requesting a 30-day extension under Rule 30.4 to November 9, giving "other previously scheduled professional obligations" as the reason. It was granted on September 22: the docket reads "Motion to extend the time to file a response is granted and the time is extended to and including November 9, 2026." So October 8 is no longer the operative date, the earliest the Justices could look at this case slips by a month, and the same slip reaches the cases waiting on this one.
Four votes are needed to grant review. Most petitions are denied, so the base rate here is against a hearing, and neither a grant nor a denial would decide the merits by itself.
The question is moving in the lower courts at the same time. A Wisconsin judge stayed the Ho-Chunk Nation's case on September 11 and certified it for the Seventh Circuit, and the Ninth Circuit held on September 16 that Kalshi's contracts are class III gaming on tribal land. The petition itself is already being used as a reason to stop other cases: in a private gambling-loss suit against Kalshi in Illinois, a plaintiff filed a motion on September 16 asking the court to freeze proceedings until the Seventh Circuit and the Supreme Court have dealt with this question.
If you are deciding where to spend money this month, none of it is a reason to change anything. The practical checks stay the same ones: whether a brand accepts players in your state, what its own rules say about redeeming there, and what it publishes in writing. Our state legality guide and the brands we rank both set out the documents we could actually read.
Sources & documents
- Supreme Court docket for No. 26-299, Flaherty v. KalshiEX, LLC - the filing and docketing dates, the extensions and the November 9 response deadline, read from the Court's own docket file dated September 15, 2026 and re-read on September 21 and September 24, 2026
- Kalshi's request for an extension of time to file its brief in opposition, September 18, 2026 - the one-page letter asking for November 9, downloaded and read in full; the docket records the motion granted on September 22, 2026
- Petition for a writ of certiorari - 332 pages with appendix; the question presented, the circuit-split section and every figure quoted above
- Plaintiff's motion to stay in Lavery v. Kalshi Inc., N.D. Ill. - the September 16 filing that cites this petition as a reason to pause a separate case
- Docket in Lavery v. Kalshi Inc., No. 1:25-cv-14184 - where that motion was entered
- Docket in KalshiEX, LLC v. Assad, No. 25-7516 (9th Cir.) - the September 9, 2026 petition for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc, entry 206, first reported in our own coverage of that decision
21+ only. Nothing above is legal advice, and no court has ruled on whether any sweepstakes casino is lawful in your state. If gambling stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER or read our responsible gaming resources.
Sources & documents
- www.supremecourt.gov/rss/cases/JSON/26-299.json
- www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-299/422751/20260902102245623_26-_PetitionForWritOfCertiorari.pdf
- www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-299/424953/20260918212129443_Flaherty%20v.%20Kalshi%20-%20BIO%20Extension%20Letter.pdf
- storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ilnd.490262/gov.uscourts.ilnd.490262.42.0.pdf
- www.courtlistener.com/docket/71936635/lavery-v-kalshi-inc/
- www.courtlistener.com/docket/72237443/kalshiex-llc-v-assad/
Every factual claim in this article maps to one of the sources above - that is the publishing bar, not a goal.
FAQ
Has the Supreme Court agreed to hear this?
No. A petition for certiorari has been filed and docketed. The Court has not granted review, and the respondent's brief in opposition is not due until November 9, 2026, after the Court granted Kalshi a 30-day extension on September 22, 2026.
Does this case involve a sweepstakes casino?
No. The parties are New Jersey gaming officials and KalshiEX, LLC, a prediction-market exchange. No sweepstakes operator is a party and no sweepstakes rule is at issue.
Could this change where I can play sweeps games?
Not by itself. State sweepstakes bans rest on state gambling statutes, not on the Commodity Exchange Act. A ruling that federal commodities law displaces state gambling law in this corner would be argued by others elsewhere, but it would not automatically reopen any state.
When will we know if the Court takes it?
There is no fixed date, and the clock has already slowed down once. After the response is filed the petition is distributed for conference, and the Court then announces a grant or denial in an order list. No conference is scheduled on this docket, and the extension granted on September 22 pushed Kalshi's response from October 8 to November 9. We will report the outcome when the docket shows it.
Free SC drops, new casinos, and law changes - for your state.
One email a week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime. If your state bans sweeps, you get law updates instead of offers - that's the point.