Kalshi Tribal-Land Bets Are Class III Gaming: Ninth Circuit
- NOV 7, 2026 - The district court has now acted on the remand this article described. On November 4, 2026, Judge Corley granted the tribes' preliminary injunction motion (entry 106) and enjoined Kalshi Inc. and KalshiEX from offering any sports contracts on the tribes' Indian lands; the tribes must send Kalshi boundary maps by November 13 and Kalshi must report on compliance within 21 days. The order does not name the Robinhood defendants. The Ninth Circuit's mandate in this appeal issued on October 8. We also correct an error. This article said, from first publication, that no court had ordered Kalshi to stop anywhere. That was wrong when written: our own earlier reports record state-court orders against Kalshi's sports contracts in Massachusetts, as recounted in a complaint filed by Novig, and in Michigan, as recited in a court stipulation. The sentence has been removed rather than updated. Two other things moved. On October 27 the Seventh Circuit granted Kalshi's petition for permission to appeal in the Ho-Chunk case, No. 26-8020, and denied the Ho-Chunk Nation's cross-petition; this article said nothing had been granted there. On November 4 the Ninth Circuit denied Kalshi's petitions for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc in the Nevada appeal, No. 25-7516, which this article described as pending. The lead, the disposition paragraph, the timeline, the case-status section, the closing section and two FAQ answers have been updated. Full report on the injunction: /news/kalshi-tribal-lands-injunction-california/.
- SEP 26, 2026 - Two things this article said were unknown are now on the record. First, the September 24 status conference: the minute entry reached the public docket on September 25 as entry 98, and it answers the question this piece left open. Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley heard the tribes' motion for leave to amend by Zoom and did not lift the stay, because "The Ninth Circuit has not issued their mandate regarding this action." The parties must notify the court when the mandate issues, at which point she will set a further status conference and, if necessary, a briefing schedule; in the meantime they are to meet and confer. The sentences saying nothing from that date had reached the docket have been replaced with what the entry says. Second, the Seventh Circuit. This article said the Ho-Chunk certified appeal was before "a court that has not yet been asked to take it". It has been asked: Kalshi Inc. and KalshiEX LLC filed a Petition for Permission to Appeal under 28 U.S.C. section 1292(b) on September 21, 2026, docketed the next day as No. 26-8020 in the Seventh Circuit, from W.D. Wis. No. 3:25-cv-00698. That was already true when we re-verified this piece on September 25 and we missed it; our separate report on the Wisconsin certification was corrected and this one was not. Nothing has been granted there, and the Seventh Circuit remains free to refuse the petition. The September 16 Ninth Circuit disposition, the pending rehearing question in No. 25-7516 and the absence of any rehearing petition in this appeal are all unchanged.
- SEP 25, 2026 - A date this article was written ahead of has passed. The September 24, 2026 status conference before Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley, which this piece described in the present and future tense and said we would report on, is now behind us, and the sentences saying it is upcoming have been put into the past. We cannot yet say what happened at it: re-read on September 25, the public mirror of the district docket still ends at entry 97 of September 18, a notice of appearance, with no minute entry for the conference. RECAP lags the court's own system, so that silence is not a finding, and the article now says so rather than leaving a reader to assume the conference was cancelled. Nothing else moved. The September 16 Ninth Circuit disposition, the pending rehearing question in No. 25-7516 and the tribes' motion for leave to amend are all as reported.
The Ninth Circuit held on September 16, 2026 that Kalshi's sports event contracts are class III gaming under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, and that they happen on Indian lands when a user buys one while standing on a reservation. The same opinion holds that the Commodity Exchange Act's "exclusive jurisdiction" clause does not shut federal courts out of the question. Two California tribes had been refused a preliminary injunction against Kalshi and Robinhood; the panel reversed that refusal and sent the case back. The panel did not itself order Kalshi to stop. On November 4 the district judge did, on these tribes' lands, as our report on the Kalshi tribal-lands injunction sets out. No sweepstakes casino is a party to any of it. What changed is the argument: the "exclusive jurisdiction" defence that the wider "this is not gambling" industry leans on has now failed in this court twice in nineteen days.
The case is Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi, Inc., No. 25-7504, an appeal from the Northern District of California. The appellants are two federally recognised California tribes, Blue Lake Rancheria and the Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians. The defendants are Kalshi, Inc. and KalshiEX LLC together with Robinhood Markets, Inc. and Robinhood Derivatives LLC, which the opinion describes as acting as "a retail distributor for Kalshi's products" - so the holding reaches the app most retail users actually buy these contracts through, not only Kalshi's own.
Judge M. Margaret McKeown wrote for a panel that also included Chief Judge Mary H. Murguia and Judge Richard A. Paez. It is a published opinion, argued on July 10 and filed on September 16. We downloaded the 38-page opinion from the court's own site and read it in full, which is how we check everything we publish.
We flagged this appeal as the thing to watch when we reported that the district court case was frozen waiting on it. It is no longer pending.
What did the Ninth Circuit decide?
That the tribes are likely to win, and that the district judge got three separate questions wrong.
The opinion opens with the reader in it: "Say you live in California and want to wager whether the San Francisco Giants will win on Sunday. In California, where sports betting is illegal, you can't place your bet. Instead, you might try to buy an 'event contract' keyed to that outcome."
Under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, the tribes had to show three things. The panel found all three likely.
| What the tribes had to show | What the panel held |
|---|---|
| The contracts are "class III gaming activit[ies]" | Yes. "Kalshi may reshuffle the cards, but it cannot change the hand" |
| The contracts are "located on Indian lands" | Yes, when a user "purchases one while on a reservation", even though Kalshi's servers are not there |
| Kalshi is offering them "in violation of" the tribes' secretarial procedures | Yes, because those procedures incorporate tribal ordinances that bar unauthorised class III gaming |
On the first point the panel was blunt about method. "The analysis is functional. IGRA does not ask whether the operator labels the product a bet or an event contract, or something else. It asks what the activity looks like." It then runs the comparison itself: a user on the floor of the Blue Lake Casino Hotel opens Kalshi and DraftKings and stakes $100 on the same Giants outcome on each. "The bettor, the place, the stake, and the contingency remain the same. The only thing that changes is Kalshi's vocabulary."
The tribes lost one claim. Their Lanham Act case over Kalshi's advertisement that "Sports Betting [Is] Legal in all 50 States on Kalshi" was rejected, because a lay statement about what a statute means is opinion, not a statement of fact. The panel's reason is a sentence the industry should sit with: "The legality of Kalshi's products remains unsettled, and that state of affairs forecloses a viable Lanham Act claim."
The order is affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded, with the district court told to work through the remaining preliminary-injunction factors. The panel itself issued no injunction; the district court granted one on November 4. The parties bear their own costs.
Why does this Kalshi ruling matter to sweepstakes casino players?
Because of the third holding, which is about a phrase rather than a product.
Kalshi's central defence is that its contracts trade on a federally designated contract market, that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission has "exclusive jurisdiction" over them under 7 U.S.C. section 2(a)(1)(A), and that everything else therefore gets out of the way. The panel read that phrase narrowly. "The phrase 'exclusive jurisdiction' is not a broad grant to the Commission of control over all commodities-related matters to the exclusion of all other federal laws." And its summary: "the CEA may grant the Commission sole sway over its own field, but it neither negates IGRA nor bars federal courts from hearing a claim under it."
The panel also refused to let the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act carry Kalshi's weight. That statute excludes anything traded on a registered exchange from its definition of a bet, which Kalshi argued displaces IGRA. The opinion answers that the UIGEA "disavows any intent to 'alter[], limit[], or extend[]' existing federal, state and tribal gaming regulations", and that "Kalshi's argument confers upon the UIGEA a displacing effect that Congress expressly denied it."
A sweepstakes casino has no CFTC licence and no exchange, so none of this applies to one directly, and the CFTC has separately warned prediction markets off sweepstakes-style rewards rather than the other way round. The connection is the shape of the argument. The whole dual-currency model rests on the claim that a federal or contractual framing beats a state's own view of what gambling is, and our guide to where sweepstakes casinos are legal sets out how differently the states answer that. Three weeks ago the same court held that Kalshi's contracts are likely bets rather than swaps, so Nevada can enforce its gaming law. That decision was about state power. This one says the same phrase does not displace a separate federal statute either.
It also lands in the middle of a live fight. Six state attorneys general have been sued by Underdog since September 8 on a preemption theory of the same family, and one of those six cases sits in the Western District of Washington, inside this circuit and in the state where Kalshi began geofencing its sports markets after losing a preemption ruling in August. The amici here line up the other way: the caption records briefs "for Amici Curiae Massachusetts, California, 25 Other States, and the District of Columbia", and the attorneys general listed in that block include California, Nevada, Ohio, New Jersey, Connecticut, Washington and Louisiana. The American Gaming Association filed too, as did the Indian Gaming Association, the National Congress of American Indians and "15 Federally Recognized Tribes". Paradigm Operations LP filed separately; the opinion records the brief but not the side it argued.
Is this the end of the Kalshi tribal lands cases?
No. It settles one appeal and leaves the rest running.
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| May 22, 2026 | The district court case is stayed by order, pending this appeal |
| Jul 10, 2026 | The Ninth Circuit hears argument in No. 25-7504 |
| Aug 28, 2026 | The same court rules against Kalshi in the Nevada appeal, No. 25-7516 |
| Sep 9, 2026 | Kalshi petitions for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc in that Nevada appeal |
| Sep 11, 2026 | The Ho-Chunk Nation's IGRA case in Wisconsin is stayed and certified for a Seventh Circuit appeal |
| Sep 16, 2026 | This opinion is filed and reaches the district docket the same day, as entry 96 |
| Sep 21, 2026 | Kalshi petitions the Seventh Circuit for permission to appeal the Ho-Chunk ruling, No. 26-8020 |
| Sep 24, 2026 | Hearing before Judge Corley; she keeps the stay in place until the mandate issues |
| Oct 8, 2026 | The Ninth Circuit's mandate issues in this appeal |
| Oct 27, 2026 | The Seventh Circuit grants Kalshi's petition to appeal the Ho-Chunk ruling |
| Nov 4, 2026 | Rehearing denied in the Nevada appeal; Judge Corley grants the tribes' preliminary injunction |
The district court case was stayed by an order docketed on May 22, 2026, and Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley set a status conference for September 24 at 9:30 a.m. by Zoom, open to the public and the press. It went ahead, and the minute entry reached the public docket the next day as entry 98. She heard the tribes' motion for leave to amend and declined to lift the stay: "The Ninth Circuit has not issued their mandate regarding this action; therefore, the Court will not lift the stay." The parties are to notify her when the mandate issues, and she will then set a further status conference and, if necessary, a briefing schedule; in the interim they are to meet and confer on next steps. The entry is text-only, with no document behind it, and it records no ruling either way on the motion for leave to amend. So the case stayed frozen until the mandate, which issued on October 8. On November 4 Judge Corley granted the preliminary injunction against Kalshi Inc. and KalshiEX. The appellate outcome itself reached that docket the same day it was filed: entry 96 on September 16, a text-only clerk entry labelled "USCA Memorandum" with no public document behind it. A third tribe, Picayune Rancheria of the Chukchansi Indians, was dismissed from the appeal without prejudice after oral argument by joint stipulation.
Separately, the Ho-Chunk Nation's IGRA case against Kalshi and Robinhood in Wisconsin was stayed on September 11 and certified for a Seventh Circuit appeal, and that court has now been asked to take it: Kalshi Inc. and KalshiEX LLC filed a Petition for Permission to Appeal under 28 U.S.C. section 1292(b) on September 21, 2026, docketed the next day as No. 26-8020. On October 27, 2026 the Seventh Circuit granted that petition and denied the Ho-Chunk Nation's cross-petition, so it will hear the appeal. A third tribal case is running in New Mexico, where four tribes argued their injunction motion on September 23 and, as of entry 63 on October 21, Judge Margaret Strickland had not ruled (our report on the New Mexico tribes' hearing). The Ninth Circuit's opinion here notes that the Tenth Circuit has already read the same IGRA cause-of-action provision the same way, in Comanche Nation v. Ware, 174 F.4th 717 (10th Cir. 2026).
The August ruling this one builds on has now cleared rehearing. Kalshi petitioned for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc in No. 25-7516 on September 9, 2026, and on November 4 the panel denied both; its order says no judge requested a vote on rehearing en banc. The mandate in this appeal issued on October 8.
For a reader deciding where to spend money this week, none of that changes anything. None of these cases touches a sweepstakes site's availability or your balance. The one thing worth acting on is narrower: if a sweeps brand markets sports wagering to you, the question to ask is which document authorises it, in your state, in writing. Sportzino is the only brand we rank that runs a real sportsbook beside its casino, and our review sets out the 16 states where its own Sweeps Rules bar redemption. Every brand we rank is listed with the paperwork we could actually read.
Sources & documents
- Opinion in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi, Inc., No. 25-7504 - 38 pages, filed September 16, 2026, the source of every quotation above
- Ninth Circuit opinions page - where the decision was listed as filed on September 16
- District court docket, Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi, Inc. and its entry list - the May 22 stay, the September 14 order setting the September 24 conference, entry 96 on September 16, and entry 98, the September 24 minute entry refusing to lift the stay, which is the source of the quotation from it; re-read September 26, 2026
- Opinion in KalshiEX, LLC v. Assad, No. 25-7516 - the August 28 ruling this opinion repeatedly relies on
- Kalshi Inc. v. Ho-Chunk Nation, No. 26-8020 (7th Cir.) - the petition for permission to appeal under 28 U.S.C. section 1292(b), filed September 21, 2026 and docketed September 22, read September 26, 2026, and the October 27, 2026 order (entry 9) granting it and denying the cross-petition, read November 7, 2026
- KalshiEX, LLC v. Assad, No. 25-7516, docket - entry 231, the November 4, 2026 order denying panel rehearing and rehearing en banc
- Order re: preliminary injunction, November 4, 2026 (PDF) - district court entry 106
21+ only. Nothing above is legal advice, and no court has ruled on whether any sweepstakes casino is lawful in your state. If gambling stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER or read our responsible gaming resources.
How we rate the brands involved
Sources & documents
- cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2026/09/16/25-7504.pdf
- www.ca9.uscourts.gov/opinions/
- www.courtlistener.com/docket/70884560/blue-lake-rancheria-v-kalshi-inc/
- www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/search/?q=docket_id%3A70884560&type=rd&order_by=entry_date_filed+desc
- cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2026/08/28/25-7516.pdf
- www.courtlistener.com/docket/74837057/kalshi-inc-v-ho-chunk-nation/
- www.courtlistener.com/docket/72237443/kalshiex-llc-v-assad/
- storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.453216/gov.uscourts.cand.453216.106.0_2.pdf
Every factual claim in this article maps to one of the sources above - that is the publishing bar, not a goal.
FAQ
Did the Ninth Circuit shut Kalshi down?
No. It reversed the refusal of a preliminary injunction and sent the case back to the district judge, and the ruling is limited to class III gaming on the two tribes' lands. On November 4, 2026 the district judge granted the injunction, barring Kalshi from offering sports contracts on the tribes' Indian lands.
Does this decision mention sweepstakes casinos?
Not once. It is about event contracts, IGRA, the UIGEA and the Commodity Exchange Act. It matters here because it narrows the "exclusive jurisdiction" argument that the broader "this is not gambling" industry relies on.
Does this ruling affect Sportzino's sportsbook?
No. It is about event contracts sold on a federally designated exchange, and a sweepstakes brand does not run one. Sportzino's sports product is governed by its own Sweeps Rules, which bar redemption in 16 states, and nothing in this opinion changes where any sweepstakes brand can operate.
Which states does the ruling bind?
It is a published Ninth Circuit opinion, so it binds the federal district courts of that circuit, which covers nine western states plus Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands. Courts elsewhere may follow it or not. The Tenth Circuit has read the same IGRA cause-of-action provision the same way.
What happens next in this case?
The mandate issued on October 8, 2026, and on November 4 Judge Corley granted the preliminary injunction against Kalshi. The tribes must send Kalshi maps of their lands by November 13, and Kalshi must file a compliance report within 21 days of the order.
Free SC drops, new casinos, and law changes - for your state.
One email a week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime. If your state bans sweeps, you get law updates instead of offers - that's the point.