Polymarket Sues New York AG Over Gambling Law Preemption
- OCT 7, 2026 - The joint letter has been filed, and it went on the other docket. The October 5 note below says it "was due around October 7; re-read on October 5, 2026 it has not been filed and the September 30 order is still the newest entry". On October 6, 2026 three entries appeared on the related case, 1:26-cv-08338, the state's removed petition: entry 14 labelled "Remand to State Court", entry 15 "Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion" and entry 16 "Letter", timestamped by the Southern District of New York's own filing feed on the evening of October 6 New York time. Entry 16 is the first filing on either docket capable of being the joint letter the September 30 order called for. Nothing has been docketed on this case, 1:26-cv-08345, where that order remains the newest entry, and no judge has ruled on the stay question. The other development a reader needs is that remand is now in play: a bare clerk's label of "Remand to State Court" is the label for a motion rather than an order granting one, so no court has sent the state's case back, but somebody has asked it to. The free mirror records no filer and no retrievable document for any of the three, so we do not say who filed what. The stay section and the joint-letter FAQ are corrected. Everything else is unchanged: the nine named defendants, the case numbers, the September 24 filing sequence and the relatedness history.
- OCT 5, 2026 - A stay is now on the table in both cases, and the September 30 note below said "nothing has been decided in either case" without recording the order that put it there. On September 30, 2026, hours after that note was written, District Judge Ronnie Abrams signed entry 26: it takes the case "for all purposes" and directs that "within seven days, the parties in this case and in the related case QCX LLC v. James, No. 26-CV-8345, confer and submit a joint letter advising the Court on whether they seek to proceed to an initial status conference, or to stay proceedings pending the resolution of" three Second Circuit appeals - KalshiEX LLC v. Williams, No. 26-1835; KalshiEx LLC v. Cafferelli, No. 26-2239; and Coinbase Financial Markets, Inc. v. Tong, No. 26-2297. The order decides nothing on the merits, so the earlier note was right about that, but asking both sides whether the case should wait on three appeals that were docketed before this complaint was filed is a development a reader needs. A new section and the "has any judge ruled on it" FAQ now set it out. The joint letter was due around October 7; re-read on October 5, 2026 it has not been filed and the September 30 order is still the newest entry. Everything else is unchanged: the nine named defendants, the case numbers, the September 24 filing sequence and the relatedness history.
- SEP 30, 2026 - Both of the cases this article keeps apart are now in front of the same judge, and this article said no judge was assigned to either. On September 25, 2026 the state's removed petition, 1:26-cv-08338, was assigned to District Judge Ronnie Abrams with Magistrate Judge Valerie Figueredo designated. Polymarket's own suit, 1:26-cv-08345, opened to "Judge Unassigned" the same day and was referred to Judge Abrams as possibly related; Polymarket filed a statement of relatedness on September 28, and on September 29 the docket recorded "CASE ACCEPTED AS RELATED. Create association to 1:26-cv-08338-RA" and reassigned it to Judge Abrams, with Judge Figueredo designated there too. The body and the FAQ have been corrected. The two cases keep their own numbers, parties and claims - that part of this article is unchanged - but they are now managed together, which is the practical answer to the question the article raises about why the complaint never mentions the state's petition. Nothing has been decided in either case.
Polymarket US sued New York Attorney General Letitia James and all eight officials of the New York State Gaming Commission in federal court on September 24, 2026. The 31-page complaint asks a judge to declare New York's civil and criminal gambling laws preempted as applied to Polymarket, and to enjoin every one of those officials from enforcing them. It was filed about five and a half hours after Polymarket removed the state's own case against it to the same courthouse.
The case is QCX LLC d/b/a Polymarket US v. James, No. 1:26-cv-08345, in the Southern District of New York. The clerk classified it as nature of suit 950, "Constitutional - State Statute", brought on federal-question jurisdiction with a jury demanded by the plaintiff.
Who exactly did Polymarket sue?
Nine people, every one of them in their official capacity. Attorney General Letitia James is the first named defendant. The other eight run the New York State Gaming Commission: Chair Brian O'Dwyer, Vice Chair Peter J. Moschetti, Jr., Commissioners John A. Crotty, Sylvia B. Hamer, Martin J. Mack, Marissa Shorenstein and Jerry Skurnik, and Executive Director Robert Williams. Paragraph 21 says all eight "have the power and duty to enforce New York gaming laws, including the laws preempted by federal law".
Gibson Dunn & Crutcher filed it, signed by Orin Snyder. The Rule 7.1 statement filed alongside it names two corporate parents, QCL Quad Code USA Corporation and Blockratize Inc., plus five affiliates: QC Tech LLC, A2 QSS LLC, QC Clearing LLC, Coming Home GBA LLC and PM Derivatives LLC. The clerk's text for the same disclosure in the removal case, docketed five hours earlier that afternoon, names the same seven entities in the same order.
What is Polymarket asking the court to do?
Two things, both sweeping:
- A declaratory judgment that "New York's civil and criminal gaming, gambling, and wagering laws are preempted under the CEA as applied to Plaintiff".
- Preliminary and permanent injunctions stopping the defendants from enforcing those laws "or any other state law or regulation to the extent it purports to regulate or prohibit Plaintiff's activities governed exclusively by federal law".
There is exactly one count: Commodity Exchange Act preemption, pleaded three ways over 22 paragraphs as express preemption, field preemption and conflict preemption. The vehicle is the Supremacy Clause and Ex parte Young. No damages are sought.
Why does the complaint never mention the case New York filed that day?
It is drafted as a pre-enforcement suit, and on its face the state's petition does not exist. We searched all 31 pages: the complaint never cites case number 1:26-cv-08338, never uses the phrase "special proceeding", and never names Executive Law § 63(12), the statute carrying all eight of New York's causes of action. What it says instead, at paragraph 74, is that Polymarket "faces the imminent threat of enforcement by New York". Paragraph 76 calls that enforcement "near-certain". Whether that reflects drafting that began before the state filed, or a deliberate choice to plead around it, is not something the document says and not something we will guess at.
The evidence it offers for that threat is the state's record against everyone else. Paragraph 72 recites the April 21, 2026 suits against Coinbase Financial Markets and Gemini Titan, "all apparently without sending cease-and-desist letters", and the July 31, 2026 suit against KalshiEX. Paragraph 2 says the defendants "have pursued crushing civil and criminal penalties against three other CFTC-regulated entities that offer event contracts, each time accompanied by a temporary restraining order". Footnote 1 quotes the Attorney General's own February 2, 2026 consumer alert: prediction markets "may appear as modern, high-tech platforms for speculation or 'forecasting,' but in practice, many operate as unregulated gambling".
One more tell sits on the signature page. It reads "Attorneys for Defendant QCX LLC, d/b/a Polymarket US" in a document where QCX is the plaintiff, which is the sort of thing that happens when two filings are built in one afternoon.
What happened on September 24, and in what order?
The court's own public filing feed stamps both events on September 24. Here is the sequence it records, in Eastern time:
| Time (ET) | Case | Entry |
|---|---|---|
| 1:02 p.m. | 1:26-cv-08338 | Notice of Removal, moving New York's petition into federal court |
| 6:32 p.m. | 1:26-cv-08345 | Complaint, Polymarket's own suit against James and the Gaming Commission |
| 6:33 to 7:08 p.m. | 1:26-cv-08345 | Civil cover sheet, Rule 7.1 statement, nine summons requests |
| 7:49 to 7:59 p.m. | both cases | Notices of appearance by Adam Israel Steene and Amanda LeSavage, both of Gibson Dunn, filed into each docket in turn |
So the defensive move and the offensive one landed within seven hours of each other, out of the same office, on one afternoon and evening. We covered the removal and the state petition behind it yesterday. This second case is separate: its own number, its own $405 filing fee and receipt number, and its own set of nine summonses. No judge appeared on either docket when we first read them.
They are both in front of one judge now. On September 25 the state's removed petition was assigned to District Judge Ronnie Abrams, and this case, which opened to "Judge Unassigned" the same day, was referred to her as possibly related. Polymarket filed a statement of relatedness on September 28, and on September 29 the docket recorded the association to 1:26-cv-08338-RA and reassigned this case to Judge Abrams as well, with Magistrate Judge Valerie Figueredo designated in both. So the pleading choice described above - a complaint drafted as though the state's petition did not exist - now has to be run past a judge who is holding the state's petition in her other hand.
Is this case about to be frozen?
It might be, and the judge raised the possibility herself rather than waiting for a party to.
Entry 26 on this case's docket, signed by Judge Abrams on September 30, 2026, is the first substantive order in it. It records that "this case has been assigned to me for all purposes" and then directs that "within seven days, the parties in this case and in the related case QCX LLC v. James, No. 26-CV-8345, confer and submit a joint letter advising the Court on whether they seek to proceed to an initial status conference, or to stay proceedings pending the resolution of" three Second Circuit appeals, which it names as KalshiEX LLC v. Williams, No. 26-1835, docketed July 8, 2026; KalshiEx LLC v. Cafferelli, No. 26-2239, docketed August 12, 2026; and Coinbase Financial Markets, Inc. v. Tong, No. 26-2297, docketed August 17, 2026.
One oddity in that text is worth stating rather than smoothing over, because a reader checking our work will hit it. On this case's docket the order names "QCX LLC v. James, No. 26-CV-8345" as "the related case", and 26-cv-8345 is this case - on its face it points at itself. The explanation is that the same order was entered on both files: it is entry 7 on the state's removed petition, 1:26-cv-08338, captioned James v. QCX LLC, where "this case" is 08338 and the cross-reference to 08345 reads correctly, and entry 26 here. We read both dockets on October 5, 2026. So the order was drafted for 08338 and copied across, and it binds the parties in both cases either way.
Read what that list is. All three are federal preemption appeals over event contracts, and the third is the Connecticut case this article already points to below. The judge is asking whether the question Polymarket brought her is worth briefing at all before the Second Circuit answers it in someone else's case. The order does not stay anything, decide anything or indicate a view on the merits; it asks the parties what they want. But a stay is now on the table in both cases at the court's own suggestion, and if one is entered, the preemption fight this complaint picked moves to Connecticut and New York appeals that were docketed months before it was filed.
The joint letter it calls for was due around October 7, 2026, and it has been filed - on the other docket. Re-read on October 7, the September 30 order is still the newest entry in this case, while 08338 gained three entries on October 6: entry 14, which the clerk labels "Remand to State Court", entry 15, "Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion", and entry 16, "Letter". Entry 16 is the first filing on either docket capable of being that joint letter. The Southern District of New York's own public filing feed timestamps all three on the evening of October 6 New York time, which is independent confirmation they exist, and none of the three is free to read.
Read entry 14 carefully, because the label invites a misreading. A bare clerk's label of "Remand to State Court" is the label for a motion, not for an order granting one. No court has sent the state's petition back to Manhattan; somebody has asked it to, and the free mirror records no filer for any of the three entries, so we are not telling you who. What a reader can take from it is that the venue fight over the state's removed petition is now live alongside the stay question, and Judge Abrams has ruled on neither.
What does this mean for sweepstakes players in New York?
It is the clearest illustration yet of why dual-currency casinos folded in New York and prediction markets did not, and the overlap is not loose. Polymarket's own paragraph 72 says New York pleaded Penal Law §§ 225.05, 225.10 and 225.20 against Coinbase, Gemini and Kalshi. Two of those three sections, 225.10 and 225.20, are the ones the Attorney General's office used against VGW, the largest sweepstakes operator in the market, alongside Executive Law § 63(12). Same office, same statutes, opposite outcomes.
The difference is that a CFTC-designated contract market can walk into federal court and argue that Congress took the subject away from the state. A sweeps operator has no federal regulator to point at. One operator did come at this from the sweepstakes side: Novig added a CFTC-designated exchange through a subsidiary and sued James on the same preemption theory in August, and its sweeps coins are now retired. VGW never tested it: it stopped selling in New York in June 2025, six months before the state's sweepstakes ban was even signed, and on September 9 it settled for $8 million on those general gambling provisions rather than litigate. The sweepstakes statute appears in the findings of that settlement only as background. That settlement is also the one live thing on this page for a New York reader: page five of the signed Assurance opens a redemption right for players who never received VGW's 2025 phase-out email, running to August 31, 2027.
Whether that argument works is still genuinely unsettled. Connecticut's federal court rejected it in August, a Washington court rejected it and ordered geofencing, and New Jersey has asked the Supreme Court to resolve the split.
Nothing filed on September 24 changes what a New York player can legally do today, and the only thing here that is worth acting on is a deadline that predates it. Sweeps coins are out: S5935A took effect the day Governor Hochul signed it, December 5, 2025. If you held VGW Sweeps Coins on June 2, 2025 and never got the phase-out email, the claim window from that settlement is the live item, not this docket, and it closes on August 31, 2027. Our guide to where sweepstakes casinos are legal tracks the states that have made the same call as New York, and if you are somewhere brands still operate, the best sweepstakes casinos list is built around exactly those state lines.
Sources & documents
- Docket, QCX LLC d/b/a Polymarket US v. James, No. 1:26-cv-08345 (S.D.N.Y.) - case number, the nine named defendants, nature of suit, and every entry cited above, read September 25, re-read September 30 and again on October 5, 2026. The September 30 read is the source for the September 25 referral to Judge Abrams, the September 28 statement of relatedness and the September 29 acceptance as related and reassignment; the October 5 read is the source for the text of entry 26, Judge Abrams' September 30 order, and for the fact that it is still the newest entry. We also read the docket of the related case, 1:26-cv-08338, on October 5, where the same order is entry 7
- Complaint for declaratory judgment and injunctive relief, 31 pages - the source of every paragraph number, quotation and prayer item in this article
- Southern District of New York public filing feed - the timestamps in the table, published by the court in GMT and converted to Eastern here
- CourtListener entry search for Polymarket filings since September 21 - how the second case was found
- Attorney General James and Governor Hochul announce lawsuit against Polymarket - the state's September 24 release
We found this case on the court's own records, not in a press release, and neither side had commented on it publicly when we published. Polymarket's characterisations of New York's conduct are allegations in a complaint that no court has tested. We asked nothing of either party and quote only filed documents. The public mirror lags the court's live system, so the docket may have moved since we read it.
21+. Play responsibly. If gambling stops being fun, help is free and confidential: call or text 1-800-GAMBLER, or see our responsible gaming resources.
Sources & documents
- www.courtlistener.com/docket/74849372/qcx-llc-dba-polymarket-us-v-james/
- storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.673553/gov.uscourts.nysd.673553.1.0.pdf
- ecf.nysd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/rss_outside.pl
- www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/search/?type=rd&q=caseName%3A%28Polymarket%29&entry_date_filed_after=2026-09-21
- ag.ny.gov/press-release/2026/attorney-general-james-and-governor-hochul-announce-lawsuit-against-polymarket
Every factual claim in this article maps to one of the sources above - that is the publishing bar, not a goal.
FAQ
Is this the same case as New York's lawsuit against Polymarket?
No. New York's petition became federal case 1:26-cv-08338 by removal. Polymarket's own suit is 1:26-cv-08345, filed later the same day, with a different set of parties and a single preemption claim. They are separate cases, but since September 29, 2026 they have been formally related and both sit with District Judge Ronnie Abrams.
Has any judge ruled on it?
No. As of September 25, 2026 the docket showed 14 entries: the complaint, a civil cover sheet, a corporate disclosure statement, nine summons requests and two notices of appearance. Since then it has gained a notice of appearance, a statement of relatedness, the case-assignment entries described above, and one order. That order, signed by Judge Abrams on September 30, decides nothing: it directs the parties in both cases to confer within seven days and say whether they want an initial status conference or a stay pending three Second Circuit preemption appeals. Nothing in it resolves any claim. Re-read on October 7, 2026 it is still the newest entry on this case. On the related docket, a letter and a motion to remand that case to state court were filed on October 6, and neither has been ruled on.
Does this affect sweepstakes casino players in New York?
Not directly. No sweepstakes operator is a party and the complaint concerns event contracts only. Sweeps coin play has been unavailable in New York since S5935A took effect on December 5, 2025, the day it was signed.
Can we read the complaint ourselves?
Yes. The complaint is free on the public court mirror and linked below. The remaining entries on the docket are behind PACER's paywall.
Free SC drops, new casinos, and law changes - for your state.
One email a week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime. If your state bans sweeps, you get law updates instead of offers - that's the point.